#1
NRMA Insurance
Read 81 reviewsReputation score: 84/100
Change service or location
2026 rankings NSW
12 Best Insurance Brokers
in Tamworth
Compare the top 12 insurance brokers in Tamworth, ranked by Google reviews and business profile details.
Data as of 27 September 2026 · 127 Google reviews across 12 listed businesses
See the 12 listings ↓Top 12 Insurance Brokers in Tamworth, NSW
1–12 of 12The shortlist
NRMA Insurance (4.6 stars from 81 Google reviews), Gallagher Insurance, Risk Management & Consulting (5.0 stars from 3 Google reviews) and MGA Insurance Group (5.0 stars from 3 Google reviews) lead LocalLocal's Tamworth insurance brokers ranking.
Compare the review count alongside each rating. Ask the business about your job, location and preferred dates before booking.
#2
Gallagher Insurance, Risk Management & Consulting
Read 3 reviewsReputation score: 70/100
#3
MGA Insurance Group
Read 3 reviewsReputation score: 70/100
#4
Ausure Tamworth
Read 3 reviewsReputation score: 70/100
#5
Elders Insurance
Read 6 reviewsReputation score: 67/100
#6
Bell Partners Wealth Creation and Financial Advisory, Accountants and Finance Brokers Tamworth & Northwest
Read 8 reviewsReputation score: 65/100
East Tamworth Medical Centre, Ste 302, Level 2/279B Marius St, Tamworth NSW 2340
(02) 6766 9655bellpartners.com#7
WFI Insurance
Read 6 reviewsReputation score: 61/100
#8
HCF
Read 6 reviewsReputation score: 57/100
#9
Tamworth Strata Management Services
Read 6 reviewsReputation score: 48/100
#10
Ironbark Advice Tamworth
Read 2 reviewsReputation score: 20/100
#11
Insurance Downunder
Read 1 reviewsReputation score: 20/100
#12
Australian Business Insurance Group
Read 2 reviewsReputation score: 12/100
129A Bridge St, West Tamworth New South Wales 2340
1300 887 230Showing 12 of 12 listings on LocalLocal. The ranking covers our Tamworth listings. How we rank businesses →
How do insurance brokers in Tamworth compare?
The 12 insurance brokers listed on LocalLocal in Tamworth have 127 Google reviews in total. Their median rating is 4.8 stars. The median review count is 4.5.
Read recent reviews about work like yours. A large review count adds context to a high rating. Confirm that the business serves your address and offers the service you need.
How the LocalLocal score works →What should you ask insurance brokers in Tamworth?
Ask insurance brokers in Tamworth about the scope, availability and charges before you book.
- Describe the work you need and confirm the business serves your address.
- Ask about availability and the experience or qualifications relevant to the job.
- Compare the written scope and charges before you book.
Questions about insurance brokers in Tamworth
Check how the rankings work and what to confirm before booking.
Which insurance brokers lead LocalLocal's Tamworth ranking?
NRMA Insurance (4.6 stars from 81 Google reviews); Gallagher Insurance, Risk Management & Consulting (5.0 stars from 3 Google reviews); MGA Insurance Group (5.0 stars from 3 Google reviews) lead LocalLocal's Tamworth insurance brokers list. These ratings and review counts were recorded 27 September 2026. Confirm current availability with the business.
How does LocalLocal rank insurance brokers in Tamworth?
LocalLocal ranks insurance brokers by its published score: up to 50 points for rating quality, 30 for review volume and 20 for available profile details. Ties use star rating and review count, followed by a stable business identifier.
How many insurance brokers are listed in Tamworth?
LocalLocal lists 12 insurance brokers in Tamworth. Their public profiles report 127 Google reviews in total. The median rating is 4.8 stars with a median of 4.5 reviews.
What should I ask insurance brokers before booking?
Describe the work you need and confirm the business serves your address. Ask about availability and the experience or qualifications relevant to the job. Compare the written scope and charges before you book.
How current are the ratings and business details?
These details were recorded 27 September 2026. Ratings and opening hours can change. Read recent reviews and confirm the quote and availability with the business.
How can a business correct its details?
Open the business profile and choose Update details. Describe the change and include a link we can check. LocalLocal reviews correction and removal requests before changing a listing.