#1
M&M Bakehouse Rutherford
Read 449 reviewsReputation score: 98/100
Change service or location
2026 rankings NSW
16 Best Bakeries
in Maitland
Compare the top 16 bakeries in Maitland, ranked by Google reviews and business profile details.
Collected 26 September 2026 · 1,997 reported Google reviews across 16 businesses
See the 16 listings ↓Top 16 Bakeries in Maitland, NSW
1–16 of 16The shortlist
Based on records collected 26 September 2026, M&M Bakehouse Rutherford (4.8 stars from 449 Google reviews), Blakeney's Pies (4.6 stars from 209 Google reviews) and The Icky Sticky Patisserie (4.5 stars from 475 Google reviews) lead LocalLocal's Maitland bakeries ranking.
The score describes the public review record. Read recent reviews and confirm the job with the business before booking.
#2
Blakeney's Pies
Read 209 reviewsReputation score: 96/100
#3
The Icky Sticky Patisserie
Read 475 reviewsReputation score: 87/100
2/27 Belmore Rd, Lorn New South Wales 2320
ickystickypatisserie.com.au#4
Bakers Delight Pender Place
Read 117 reviewsReputation score: 86/100
#5
Rutherford Bakehouse
Read 162 reviewsReputation score: 83/100
Shop/24 E Mall, Rutherford New South Wales 2320
(02) 4030 2130#6
East Maitland Bakehouse
Read 128 reviewsReputation score: 82/100
217 Newcastle St, East Maitland New South Wales 2323
(02) 4934 6025#7
Sweet Moments by Design
Read 36 reviewsReputation score: 79/100
#8
Greenhills bakehouse
Read 70 reviewsReputation score: 78/100
17 Mitchell Dr, East Maitland New South Wales 2323
(02) 4933 5493#9
U1R Patisserie
Read 46 reviewsReputation score: 77/100
#10
Village Walk Bakery
Read 52 reviewsReputation score: 76/100
119 Lawes St, East Maitland New South Wales 2323
(02) 4934 4850#11
The Cheesecake Shop East Maitland
Read 86 reviewsReputation score: 76/100
#12
Van Gool Patisserie
Read 35 reviewsReputation score: 74/100
344 High St, Maitland New South Wales 2320
facebook.com#13
Lady Blackbird Sourdough & Pastry
Read 69 reviewsReputation score: 72/100
414 High St, Maitland New South Wales 2320
(02) 4933 6580#14
French Hot Bread Maitland
Read 30 reviewsReputation score: 71/100
330 High St, Maitland New South Wales 2320
(02) 4933 4748#15
The Baker Bee
Read 32 reviewsReputation score: 70/100
13 Bruce St, East Maitland New South Wales 2323
thebakerbee.com.au#16
Urban Mill Bakery
Read 1 reviewsReputation score: 12/100
10 William St, East Maitland New South Wales 2323
organicfeast.com.auShowing 16 of 16 businesses. This ranking covers our Maitland listings. This is not a complete census. How we rank them →
What the numbers say about bakeries in Maitland
LocalLocal's Maitland capture includes 16 bakeries with 1,997 reported Google reviews. The median rating is 4.7 stars, backed by a median of 69.5 reviews.
A high average means more when plenty of people have contributed. Open the Google review link on a listing to check recent feedback about work like yours. Contact the business to confirm it serves your address.
Read the scoring method →Before you choose.
Questions about bakeries in Maitland and the evidence behind this list.
Who leads LocalLocal's Maitland bakeries ranking?
Based on records collected 26 September 2026, the highest-scoring businesses are M&M Bakehouse Rutherford (4.8 stars from 449 Google reviews); Blakeney's Pies (4.6 stars from 209 Google reviews); The Icky Sticky Patisserie (4.5 stars from 475 Google reviews). These positions describe our captured review record, not a guarantee about the work.
How are bakeries in Maitland ranked?
LocalLocal's score gives up to 50 points for rating quality, 30 for review volume and 20 for available profile details. Equal scores are ordered by star rating, then review count, then a stable business identifier. The method is published on our methodology page.
What does the review record look like for bakeries in Maitland?
The 16 bakeries captured for Maitland hold 1,997 reported Google reviews. The median rating is 4.7 stars and the median review count is 69.5. These figures describe our sample, not every local business.
What should I check before booking?
Confirm that the business serves your address and handles your type of work. Read recent Google reviews, ask about any relevant licences or registration, and get the scope and charges in writing.
How current are these details?
The listings were collected 26 September 2026. This is a dated snapshot, not a live Google feed. Confirm current hours, availability and pricing with the business.
Can a business update its listing?
Yes. Open the business profile and select Update details. Explain the correction and include a public source. Correction and removal requests are reviewed before the record changes.